We were "woken" in the middle of the night to speak to an entity calling himself the Gentleman. He told us that the Lady was lying to us, which is apparently true. We were supposed to cut the number of townspeople down to equal the number of Demons, then we'd beat the Lady. We were told that everyone put to sleep would be able to be saved, so none of us thought anything about choosing our targets during the night. We could have refused to select anyone, but no one thought about that. I guess we were too riled up about the whole thing.